Additional Tax Savings through the TFSA
Posted by admin | Posted in Personal finances, Taxation | Posted on 07-02-2011-05-2008
0
TSFA’s are my favourite investment vehicle. This is a great article.
A Tax Free Savings Account (TFSA) can be used together with your RRSP or RRIF to shelter more investment income from tax.
As you prepare to file your 2010 personal income tax, you may ask: Is there another means of reducing tax on income other than the RRSP?
TFSAs and RRSPs
The answer, of course, is a resounding “YES.” It is the Tax Free Savings Account (TFSA). When you contribute to an RRSP you get a deduction that relates to your “earned income” in the preceding year and a tax reduction based on the applicable tax rate. If you start withdrawing RRSP funds, however, they are taxed at your tax rate in the year of withdrawal. Contributions to the TFSA, on the other hand, are not tax deductible and do not, therefore, create an instant tax savings as does the RRSP contribution. The TFSA does, however, offer the opportunity to those who have already contributed their annual limit to their RRSP to set aside an additional amount and shelter any investment income (capital gains, interest and dividends) earned on those funds. Withdrawals are tax free. As with RRSPs, losses in a TFSA are not tax deductible. No capital gains tax is paid at the death of the account holder. Unlike RRSPs, the property in a TFSA can be used to secure a loan.
Unused contribution room can be carried forward indefinitely.
Any resident over the age of 18 can contribute up to $5,000 per year. (This limit may be indexed based on a formula that relates to the increase in the Consumer Price Index and so is intended to grow with inflation. However, the potential increase is rounded to the nearest $500 and may therefore be nil.) If you cease to be a Canadian resident, you may continue to hold the TFSA but cannot add to it. Unused TFSA room is carried forward indefinitely. Withdrawals from a TFSA in a year are added to TFSA room in the next year. Excess contributions are subject to a penalty of 1% per month.
It is important to note that the income attribution rules do not apply if a person provides funds to enable his or her spouse or common-law partner to contribute to a TFSA.
Different Ways to Contribute
There are three types of TFSAs: deposit, annuity contract and arrangement in trust. TFSAs can be issued by banks, insurance companies, credit unions and trust companies. The eligible types of investment are generally the same as for an RRSP: cash, mutual funds, securities listed on a recognized stock exchange, guaranteed investment certificates (GICs), bonds and certain shares of small business corporations. Foreign funds can be contributed but their value in Canadian dollars cannot exceed the $5,000 limit. The TFSA can be managed by an institution or self-directed in the same way as an RRSP.
Recent Problems
The TFSA was introduced effective January 1, 2009. Some contributors were reassessed for 2009 as a result of confusion on two main issues: the transfer of a TFSA from one institution to another institution, and how the TFSA worked with respect to withdrawals and recontributions.
With regard to the first issue, some taxpayers were initially penalized by the Canada Revenue Agency (CRA) for taking funds out of one institution by cash or cheque then opening an account at another institution. The CRA considered the transfer and deposit to be opening a new TFSA account. The CRA considered this to be a separate contribution subject to the $5,000 yearly limit and thus an overcontribution. The CRA applied the 1%-per-month penalty on the amount over the $5,000 personal contribution limit.
The TFSA is not like an investment account.
The second issue arose because taxpayers believed the TFSA was like an investment account to which they could deposit up to $5,000, remove funds then redeposit them provided the amount in the account never exceeded $5,000, at any time. Unfortunately, the CRA considered this activity to be overcontributing based on the following logic.
Suppose the taxpayer deposits $5,000 on May 2 and on September 30 withdraws $3,000 to leave a balance of $2,000. If, however, on October 25 the taxpayer deposits $3,000 to top the account back up to the $5,000 limit, the CRA will consider this deposit to be a $3,000 overcontribution and levy the 1% monthly penalty.
As indicated above, funds withdrawn may be redeposited only in the following year after the contribution room has been increased. CRA will remind you each year as to the accumulated room available for contribution.
Using a TFSA in Conjunction with a RRIF
There is no cut-off age for contributions to a TFSA as there is for the RRSP. You cannot make an RRSP contribution after December 31 of the year in which you turn 71. Thus a taxpayer over 71 can transfer the mature RRSP into a Registered Retirement Income Fund (RRIF) and from there into a TFSA at the eligible contribution amount then applicable. The amounts withdrawn from the RRIF will be taxable but the investment income earned in the TFSA and any withdrawals will not be. The funds invested in the TFSA can continue to grow without tax consequences as they did in the RRSP and RRIF.
No Dividend Tax Credit
The dividend tax credit was designed to overcome the problem of taxing income first in the hands of the corporation that earned it, then again in the hands of the shareholder. As with dividends received in an RRSP or RRIF, dividends from qualified Canadian corporations received in a TFSA cannot make use of the dividend tax credit since they are already tax sheltered. On the other hand, if a TFSA held a GIC, the interest income would be tax free whereas if held outside of a TFSA the interest would be taxable. If you have investments both inside and outside your TFSA, it may therefore be better to hold dividend yielding investments outside and interest bearing investments inside.
Is the TFSA Right for You?
Determining whether to place your 2011 investment within an RRSP or a TFSA is a decision that should be discussed with your Chartered Accountant to determine whether there are significant benefits of choosing one vehicle over the other. The end game is to increase financial security with investment strategies that reduce the taxes paid.
